Raylee Law Debate Approaches

The 2027 West Virginia Legislative Session that starts in January is likely to pass a version of Raylee’s Law, having barely escaped passing one this year. Why would homeschoolers possibly be opposed to a law that protects children from abuse? Because identifying abuse is not the central tenet of the introduced bills; homeschooling is.

It is important that homeschooling families become familiar with the issues in Raylee’s Law which can be found here, with details about the case here. It is likely that we will have our hands full when the session opens.

Much of the legislative debate hinges on the assumption that children are safe in public schools. But Delegate Kathie Hess Crouse recently countered that assumption aptly. With her permission, these are her words from September 4, 2026:

According to reports, the principal of Brooke High School was arrested after recording devices were allegedly discovered in areas used by female students, including girls’ locker and dressing rooms. If these allegations are proven, young women were violated in a place where they had every right to expect privacy and safety.

And yet, I continue to hear the argument that parents who choose to homeschool, private school, microschool, or another alternative somehow put their children at greater risk simply because those children are not inside a traditional public school.

We need to stop pretending that simply being inside a public school building automatically makes a child safe.

We have seen allegations and cases involving sexual misconduct, physical abuse, and the mistreatment and verbal abuse of students—including some of our most vulnerable children with special needs. This latest case should be another reminder that institutions are not inherently safe simply because they are government-run.

None of this means that every public school or every educator is bad. Far from it. West Virginia has many wonderful teachers, administrators, aides, coaches, and school employees who love their students and work incredibly hard for them. But we cannot use those good people as an excuse to ignore serious failures when they happen.

Parents know their children. Parents have the right—and the responsibility—to decide where their children will be safest, best educated, and best cared for.

As Delegate Crouse alludes, the situation with Principal James is, sadly, not an anomaly. Homeschool leaders have collected news reports about multiple abuse cases discovered in West Virginia public schools over the past decade or more, most by the hand of employees. Indeed, Delegate Elliot Pritt, staunch supporter of Raylee’s Law as recently as this past March, has been indicted on three counts since he was accused this summer of sexual predation and abuse of a minor over two years in the public school where he was a respected teacher.

Protecting children from abuse must not rest on the errant assumption that abuse is less likely in public school—because that has not been shown to be true. Neither has the assumption that abuse will be caught and reported in public school. The abuse at the hand of Pritt was reported by the victim’s parents, not school personnel. And the abuse of Raylee herself was not hidden, but rather identified multiple times from the time she was two.

Please begin praying now. Pray for the protection and discovery of abused children in any and every situation. Pray for legislators to care more about truth and wisdom than about scoring points in public sentiment. Pray for homeschool leaders to have wise and heard alternatives that do not treat any child unfairly, including those who are homeschooled, and which are effective without undercutting the American justice system. And last, ask for God’s mercy. He can turn hearts that are not attuned to Him.